The Bankruptcy Appellate Panel recently upheld a decision by U.S. bankruptcy judge, Boroff regarding the intersection of a common estate planning tool and bankruptcy, (see BAP NO. MW 12-060.)
Specifically the debtor had a one quarter interest in real estate that was subject to a life estate. The debtor filed bankruptcy and attempted to claim her one quarter remainder interest as exempt, pursuant to the Massachusetts Homestead statute.
The trustee objected to the exemption on the basis that the Massachusetts homestead statute does not specifically protect the debtor's type of ownership interest. The judge and panel agreed with the trustee, as the statute only protects a "sole owner, joint tenant, tenant by the entirety, tenant in common, life estate holder, or holder of a beneficial interest in a trust", none of which specifically capture the debtor's ownership type.
Despite the debtor's argument that creating a life estate with a remainder interest by simple deed is a common and cost effective estate planning tool, the court held that the specific language of the statute could not be ignored, and the legislature's failure to include remainder interests meant the homestead protection did not apply to the debtor. As such, the beneficiary of a remainder interest seeking bankruptcy protection would be better off talking to an estate planning attorney about establishing a trust in order to protect the real estate prior to filing bankruptcy.
Justin H. Dion, Esq.
Photo credit: Microsoft
Legislation that has been submitted to the Massachusetts legislature by the Real Estate Bar Association (REBA) proposes to make significant changes to what many consider to be an outdated homestead statute.
In Massachusetts, homeowners and condominium owners may file a Homestead Declaration to protect $500,000 of equity in their property. It must be filed in the Registry of Deeds for the county in which the property is located. This document protects you from creditors or judgments against you in the event that you are sued. It does not, however, protect you against existing mortgages, long-term care claims for Medicaid payments by the Division of Medical Assistance, or existing claims or lawsuits.
The new bankruptcy law signed into effect on April 20, 2005 by President Bush may affect the equity in a debtor’s home. Substantial concern has been raised with regard to the ability of a debtor to protect his or her residence. Under present Massachusetts law, debtors can elect to use the Massachusetts Homestead Exemption to protect $500,000 of equity from creditors, either in a bankruptcy or non-bankruptcy situation. Under the present law, and effective immediately from the date the law was signed by President Bush, that figure has been reduced to a maximum of $125,000 in many situations. The ability to increase the $125,000 amount will be dependent upon the length of time that the debtor has owned the home, how long he or she has lived within the state and the source of the funds used to purchase the residence. This is a major change from the former law protecting residential property from loss when faced with financial difficulties.